Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Comparison and Review: MAC Studio Fix Powder vs. Milani Multitasker Face Powder


 Word goes on and on about how similar they are and they are even dupes of each other. But lets see if they really are, shall we? 

The products themselves is pretty straight forward. But lets start with MAC first, then i'll delve into the Milani powder, and finally wrap up with its similarities or differences.

This product contains 15 grams of finely mild and fairly soft powder. The item itself is price at $27.00 and can be found on the website (Link in name).When I touch it, the powder is very soft but I wouldnt say its dense to the feeling of a creamy feeling. The product does transfer true to color and it is probably my favorite powder of all time. But granted I have only tried 8-9 powders in my life so far. This shade is in NC35 but I feel that it can be build up to a point where if you are an NC 37 or NC 40, this is not too forgiving and will show up as too light for the skin. I'm currently leaning on the NC32 (haha) side and this product is still working for me. I dont think I will get any lighter, and considering it is approaching spring time, so i will say that this product will keep working for me for the rest of the year until winter time rolls around again. I love how there is a mirror on the inside without sacrificing its slim and sleek packing. Grade? A





This product contains 10 grams and can be purchased on their website for $6.99. Although this product is sold in drugstores and the prices do fluctuate (-.50 cents or + $1 to $2).
Right off the bat, i think a positive aspect of this powder is how great the range of colors are even for a drugstore face powder. Of course, Higher end products do come in more shades but considering this is a drugstore face powder, their range of colors can indeed suit multiple skin tones.
My shade at the moment is 04 Light Tan. At first, I thought I could be a Tan based on its appearance in its clear lid. But when swatched, unfortunately, the product does come out darker than it appears in its pan. But knowing this fact, I hope this will make it easier for you to find your shade. Speaking of its con sides, lets discuss those things shall we? The packaging is a bit bulky but I dont blame them, they want to have a compartment to put a sponge in and also an area for a mirror (which could be found in the bottom compartment along with the sponge). Another con of this product is the scent. This is probably not news to you, but the scent is very floral and it smells like an old perfume bottle my grandma could've owned. But after applying, the scent does wave away and you are just left with the coloration and no more smell! :)
The product does not go on streaky or patchy, but I find that if i blend this product onto just one spot with a concentrated amount of product, the powder can look cakey. But no problem there, just dont buff in the product right away. Now, i place the powder into a larger area of the face and then buff altogether. Grade? A-





Swatched side by side on arm


 Comparison
As you can see the Milani has a more prominent yellow undertone that would cater very well with people with yellow undertones. It does for me! I dont find both of the products to be heavy or cakey feeling (after having to adjust the way i apply the Milani). It wears well, and I know that because when i take off my makeup with a make up wipe before washing my face, the product transfer into my wipe heavily. Personally, I think the Milani powder is not as soft or buttery feel as the MAC powder. The coverage is definitely the same and can be built up. The only thing I'm going to recommend is not be fooled by the Milani colors, the color you think is a right match for you may just be a little too dark.

VERDICT: I think they are not complete dupes of each other because 1) Color selection. 2) Texture in pan. But I do think they are VERY similar and will be happy with either one.

Comment below: Do you have trouble finding a correct shade in the Milani powder?
 

1 comment:

  1. Yes I'm currently having trouble now.. I don't know what color to go with :(

    ReplyDelete